Sellers read your reviews before they call you

Here's how most listings start now. Someone decides it might be time to sell. They don't ring the first agent whose name is on a sign. They open Google and type "best real estate agent" and their suburb.

What comes back is a short list of names, star ratings and review counts. Then they read. The good ones, the bad ones, and how you replied. By the time your phone rings, they've already formed an opinion. Sometimes it's an opinion about the agent down the road.

That's the job your reviews are doing. They're the first appraisal, except the seller is appraising you.

Buyers browse. Sellers shortlist.

Most review advice is written for cafes and plumbers, where the customer makes a quick call. Choosing a listing agent isn't quick. It's one of the bigger financial decisions most people make, and they know it. So they do homework.

A seller wants to know three things. Will this agent get me a good price? Will they keep me in the loop? Will it be a nightmare? Your sales history answers the first one, sort of. Your reviews answer all three, in the words of people who've been through it.

That's why a review that says "kept us informed the whole way" is worth more to your next listing than any line in your brochure. It's not you saying it.

What a seller actually sees

When someone looks you up, a few things get judged in about ten seconds.

• Your rating and your count. A 4.9 from 11 reviews reads differently to a 4.8 from 140. Volume says you've done this a lot.

• How recent they are. If your latest review is from 2023, the seller wonders what happened after that.

• Whether you reply. Replies show there's a human paying attention. Silence under a bad review is louder than the review.

• Where the reviews live. Sellers look at Google, and plenty also check realestate.com.au. Strong on one and empty on the other means you're only half showing up.

None of that is about being perfect. A profile full of recent, specific reviews with thoughtful replies beats a spotless 5.0 from six people you're related to.

The numbers, for what they're worth

BrightLocal's 2025 Local Consumer Review Survey found only 4% of consumers say they never read online reviews for local businesses, and Google was the most used place to read them. That's a US survey of general consumers, not Australian sellers, so treat it as a direction rather than gospel. If anything, the stakes go up when the "purchase" is choosing who sells your home.

Where it quietly falls apart

Most agents don't have a review problem. They have a review system problem. The reviews exist, they're just scattered.

• Google reviews in one place, realestate.com.au reviews in another, and nobody checking both.

• Great vendors who said "we'll definitely leave you a review" and then didn't, because nobody sent the link.

• A lovely review from March that never made it onto your socials, your website or your next listing presentation.

• A cranky review that's been sitting unanswered for eight months.

Every one of those is a seller who looked you up and saw less than you've actually earned.

Making your reviews do the talking

The fix isn't complicated. It's just consistent.

1. See everything in one place. You can't manage what you have to hunt for.

2. Ask at the right moment. Right after a result, not three weeks later. That's the next article in this series.

3. Reply to every review. Good or bad. Short and human is fine.

4. Put the best ones where sellers look. Your socials, your website, your appraisal pack.

That's the loop Properti Reviews is built around. It pulls your Google and realestate.com.au reviews into one inbox. You can ask for reviews by email, SMS or QR code, and one request can ask for Google and realestate.com.au together. AI drafts your replies and you approve them before anything posts to Google. Any review can become an on-brand social tile in a few clicks, and website widgets keep your best reviews on your own site, updating themselves. realestate.com.au reviews are read-only in Properti, so you can see and share them but not reply from there. Depending on your plan, requests, AI replies and widgets may need the Reviews add-on.

The short version

Your next seller is going to read your reviews before they read your brochure. Make sure there's plenty to read, that it's recent, and that you've clearly been paying attention.

Get your reviews journey started →

Not on Properti yet? See how Reviews works.