← All posts
·Reads
Your review replies are free marketing. Most agents leave them blank.
October 14, 2026
Your reply to a review isn't really for the person who wrote it. They already know how the sale went. It's for the next seller scrolling your profile, trying to work out what you're like to deal with.
That makes every reply a small piece of public marketing. Free, permanent, and sitting exactly where sellers look when they search for you. Most agents leave it blank.
Why replies matter more than you'd think
They show someone's home. A profile where every review has a reply says there's a human paying attention. That's precisely what a seller is trying to find out.
They're copy sellers actually read. Your reply is in your voice, about a real sale. It's the closest thing to a conversation a seller gets before they call.
They help your profile. Replies are public content, and they help your profile show up when sellers search.
BrightLocal's 2025 Local Consumer Review Survey found consumers are far more likely to choose a business that replies to all its reviews than one that replies to none. US consumers, not Australian sellers, but it's hard to imagine sellers caring less.
What a good reply to a great review looks like
Most five-star replies are "Thanks so much!!" and that's a wasted chance. A good reply does three things.
Uses their name and the suburb. It's real and specific.
Picks up one detail from their review. Proves you actually read it.
Says something a future seller would want to hear. Quietly. No pitch.
The shape of it, with your details dropped in:
"Thanks [name]. [Result] in [suburb] was a great run, and you made it easy by being so decisive on the day. Enjoy the next chapter. [Your name]"
Two or three sentences. Human. Done.
What a good reply to a bad review looks like
This is the one sellers read most closely, because it shows how you behave when things don't go to plan.
Don't argue in public. Even if you're right. Especially if you're right.
Acknowledge, don't grovel. "Sorry this wasn't the experience you expected" is plenty.
Take it offline. Give a name and a way to reach you.
Keep private details private. No addresses, no prices, no "as per my email on the 14th".
The shape of it:
"Hi [name], sorry to hear this. It's not the experience we want anyone to have and I'd like to understand what happened. Could you call me on [number]? [Your name]"
A calm reply under a one-star review often does more for you than another five-star review. Sellers aren't looking for perfect. They're looking for grown-up.
Tenants and buyers read too
Rental and buyer reviews show up on your profile as well, and sellers read those too. Reply to them the same way. A property manager who's clearly on top of things is a selling point for landlords, and landlords sell homes eventually.
The real problem is time
Nobody thinks replying to reviews is a bad idea. It just never gets done, because it's always the fourth most urgent thing. So reviews pile up, unanswered, across two different platforms.
That's the bit Properti Reviews is built to fix.
Your Google and realestate.com.au reviews land in one inbox, so you can see which Google reviews still need a reply.
AI drafts the reply using the details in the review. You approve it before anything posts to Google. Nothing goes out on its own.
realestate.com.au reviews are read-only, so there's no replying to those from Properti, but you can still share them.
Any review can become an on-brand social tile in a few clicks, and a workflow can auto-share your 5-star reviews as they land.
On Reviews Plus, AI insights show what clients consistently praise. Handy the next time you're writing an appraisal pitch.
The short version
Reply to every review. Make the good ones specific, make the bad ones calm, and remember the real audience is the next seller reading along.
Get your reviews journey started →
Not on Properti yet? See how Reviews works.